Improving Dispute Resolution Mechanisms in the Sino-Africa Space Cooperation

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1671-0940.2025.02.002

Abstract

Abstract: Dispute resolution mechanisms play a critical role in sustaining collaborative efforts in space exploration, particularly in partnerships involving diverse stakeholders with varying interests. This study examines the legal framework governing dispute resolution within the Sino-Africa space cooperation, analyzing foundational principles, legal theories, international treaties, national legislation, and tailored conflict-resolution mechanisms. By assessing key legal instruments such as the Outer Space Treaty (1967) and the bilateral agreements, the research explores how arbitration, mediation and adjudication processes can address disputes arising from joint space endeavors. The study highlights the importance of structured legal and procedural frameworks in mitigating conflicts, ensuring compliance, and fostering longer-term cooperation between China and African nations in space exploration. Through this analysis, the study contributes to broader discussions on enhancing the efficacy of dispute resolution mechanisms in international space collaborations.

Key words: Sino-Africa space cooperation, dispute resolution, legal framework

YANG Kuan, Amongin Sandra. Improving Dispute Resolution Mechanisms in the Sino-Africa Space Cooperation[J]. AEROSPACE CHINA, 2025, 26(2): 10-22.

References

[1] LIU H, LUO J. Sino-African Development Cooperation: Studies on the Theories, Strategies,Policies [EB/OL]. In Research Series on the Chinese Dream and China’s Development Path. Springer Nature Singapore, 2021. [2023-3-15]. https://books.google.co.jp/books?id=-Y9OEAAAQBAJ.
[2] Gerardine Meishan Goh.Dispute Settlement In International Space Law: A Multi-Door Courthouse For Outer Space[J]. Studies in Space Law, 2007, 38.
[3] Aoki S.Outer Space Treaty and Fundamental Principles[M]//International Space Law in the New Space Era: Principles and Challenges. Oxford University Press, 2024.
[4] Taylor I.The Institutional Framework of Sino-African Relations[M]//China-Africa and an Economic Transformation, 2019: 98-126.
[5] Lawal L, Chatwin C. Nigerian Communication Satellite (NIGCOMSAT-1R) Ka-Band System. 2013, 10.
[6] Jakhu R S, Pelton J N.Global Space Governance: An International Study[M/OL]//Space and Society. Springer International Publishing, 2017. [2024-12-12]. https://books.google.com.hk/books?id=6V81DwAAQBAJ
[7] Bartóki-Gönczy B, Nagy B.The Artemis Accords[J]. International Legal Materials, 2023,62(5): 888-898.
[8] Keohane R O, Martin L L.The Promise of Institutionalist Theory[J]. International Security, 1995, 20(1): 39-51.
[9] Chayes A, Chayes A H.The New Sovereignty[M]. Harvard University Press, 1995.
[10] James Clay Moltz.The Politics of Space Security: Strategic Restraint and the Pursuit of National Interests, 3rd ed[M/OL]. California: Stanford University Press, 2019. [2024-6-25]. https://searchworks.stanford.edu/view/13176178.
[11] Moamen Mohamed Sayed, LI Shouping, Zagra Alievna Gadzhieva.Interpretation and Implementation of ‘Peaceful Purposes’ in Military Activities in Outer Space: Legal and Political Implications[J]. Aerospace China, 2024, 25(3): 37-49.
[12] Ostrom E.Governing the Commons: the Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action[M]//Political Economy of Institutions and Decisions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990.
[13] Forsyth T, Johnson C.Elinor Ostrom’s Legacy: Governing the Commonsand the Rational Choice Controversy[J]. Development and Change, 2014, 45(5).
[14] Ahmad Z, Alshdaifat S A.Legal Challenges in Establishing Human Settlements in Space[C]// Al Naimiy H M K, Elmehdi H M, Shehadi I A, et al. Proceedings of the 14th Arabic Conference of the Arab Union for Astronomy and Space Sciences. Singapore: Springer Nature Singapore, 2025: 231-247.
[15] Lyall F, Larsen P B.Space Law: A Treatise. Routledge[M/OL].[2023-11-12]. https://books.google.com.hk/books?id=MGZcjwEACAAJ.
[16] Zangl B. Regime Theory[M/OL]// Theories of International Relations. Routledge, 2014:14. [2024-5-16].https://www.taylorfrancis.com/chapters/edit/10.4324/9781315797366-5/regime-theory-bernhard-zangl?context=ubx&refId=6db760c8-d269-49cf-b50c-e29a3c644612.
[17] WRC-19. Clarification on the implementation of Article 48 of the ITU Constitution by the Radiocommunication Bureau,” International Telecommunications Union, Sharm el-Sheikh, Egypt, Official Agenda item 9.3, Oct. 2019.
[18] Allison A L.The ITU and Managing Satellite Orbital and Spectrum Resources in the 21st Century[M/OL]. Springer International Publishing, 2014. https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-319-05314-1
[19] Signatories of the U.S.-Led Artemis Accords Meet in Person for the First Time[J]. American Journal of International Law, 2023,117(1): 133-139.
[20] Swenson G.Legal Pluralism in Theory and Practice[J]. International Studies Review, 2018, 20(3): 438-462.
[21] Magliveras K D, Naldi G J. The African Union (AU) [M/OL]. Wolters Kluwer, 2018. https://books.google.com.hk/books?id=KT9sDwAAQBAJ.
[22] Christodoulidis E, Dukes R, Goldoni M.Research Handbook on Critical Legal Theory[M/OL]//Research Handbooks in Legal Theory series. Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd, 2019. [2023-12-28]. https://www.e-elgar.com/shop/gbp/research-handbook-on-critical-legal-theory-9781786438881.html?srsltid=AfmBOooZKRM4HnHirxcAdIdOiCD7L72MVYsLdVXfPH0p2tVNtGNt8sza.
[23] Folashadé Soulé, Cobus van Staden, Lina Benabdallah, et al. Exploring the Role of Narratives in China-Africa Relations[R]. African Policy Research Institute, Jun.2024. https://doi.org/10.59184/sa.044.
[24] Deudney D.Dark Skies: Space Expansionism, Planetary Geopolitics, and the Ends of Humanity Space Expansionism, Planetary Geopolitics, and the Ends of Humanity[M/OL]. Oxford University Press, 2020. [2023-11-10].
[25] Adetunji J.Outer space: Rwanda and Nigeria sign an accord for more responsible exploration - why this matters[EB/OL]. The Conversation.[2024-5-10]. https://theconversation.com/outer-space-rwanda-and-nigeria-sign-an-accord-for-more-responsible-exploration-why-this-matters-203202.
[26] Kanevskaia O. Constitution of the International Telecommunication Union[EB/OL]. International Legal Materials, 2016. http://opil.ouplaw.com/view/10.1093/law-oxio/e135.013.1/law-oxio-e135?rskey=MVcULk&result=7&prd=OXIO.
[27] ITU. Radio Regulations Articles[M]. International Legal Materials, 2012.
[28] ITU. Optional Protocol on the Compulsory Settlement of Disputes Relating to the Constitution of the International Telecommunication Union, to the Convention of the International Telecommunication and to the Administrative Regulations[M]. International Legal Materials, 1994.
[29] ITU. Dispute Resolution in the Telecommunications Sector: Current Practices and Future Directions[EB/OL]. ITU, Oct.2004. [2023-11-18]. https://www.itu.int/ITU-D/treg/publications/ITU_WB_Dispute_Res-E.pdf.
[30] Utibeabasi B.Third Party Funding Under The Nigerian Arbitration And Mediation Act, 2023-A Comparative Analysis With The Legal Systems Of India, Hong Kong And Singapore[J]. SSRN, 2025 (4):10.
[31] Noyes J E.The Common Heritage of Mankind: Past, Present, and Future[J]. Denv. J. Int’l L. & Pol’y, 2011, 447:2011-2012.
[32] Alexander A, Kamath S.The Persistent Objector Rule in International Law James A [M]. Green Oxford University Press, 2016.
[33] Variath A. Lunar Mining and the Erosion of the Common Heritage Principle: What’s the Future of the Moon Agreement?[EB/OL]. CILJ, Oct.2024.[2024-12-26]. https://cilj.co.uk/2024/10/20/lunar-mining-and-the-erosion-of-the-common-heritage-principle-whats-the-future-of-the-moon-agreement/.
[34] Martinez P.The UN COPUOS Guidelines for the Long-term Sustainability of Outer Space Activities[J]. Journal of Space Safety Engineering, 2021, 8(1): 98-107.
[35] Baruzzi Sofia.China’s Export Control Law Explained[EB/OL]. China Briefing.[2023-7-30]. https://www.china-briefing.com/news/chinas-export-control-law-explainer-china-briefing-news/.
[36] Nigerian National Space Research and Development Agency. NASRDA[EB/OL].[2-23-2-18]. https://central.nasrda.gov.ng/.
[37] SANSA. South African National Space Agency[EB/OL].SANSA. [2023-1-12]. https://www.sansa.org.za/.
[38] Faleti J. The NASRDA Act.Beyond a Domestic Implementation of International Space Obligations, space in Africa[EB/OL]. [2023-5-16].https://spaceinafrica.com/2021/04/14/the-national-space-research-and-development-agency-act-beyond-a-domestic-implementation-of-international-space-obligations/.
[39] Martinez K L. Lost in Space: An Exploration of the Current Gaps in Space Law[J/OL]. Seattle Journal of Technology, Environmental & Innovation Law, 2021, 11(2). [2023-8-12]. https://digitalcommons.law.seattleu.edu/sjteil/vol11/iss2/4
[40] Ana Cristina van Oijhuizen Galhego Rosa, Juliana Macedo Scavuzzi dos Santos, Tatiana Viana. The Challenges in Drafting National Law for Space Activities - A Brazilian Experience[EB/OL]. International Institute of Space Law, 2014. [2023-8-10]. https://www.elevenjournals.com/tijdschrift/iisl/2014/5%20Recent%20Developments%20in%20Space%20Law/IISL_2014_057_005_004.pdf.
[41] North Africa Post.China expands space cooperation with African countries amid US aid cuts[EB/OL]. North Africa Post.[2025-2-17]. https://northafricapost.com/84327-china-expands-space-cooperation-with-african-countries-amid-us-aid-cuts.html.
[42] Daily Post.China-Africa Space Cooperation: Development Justice Behind Technological Collaboration[EB/OL]. Daily Post.[2025-2-20]. https://dailypost.ng/2025/02/20/china-africa-space-cooperation-development-justice-behind-technological-collaboration/.
[43] Digital Watch.China’s growing space influence in Africa[EB/OL]. Digital Watch.[2025-2-17]. https://dig.watch/updates/chinas-growing-space-influence-in-africa.
[44] Wang C.Space Law and Arbitration: An introduction to Space Law in the People’s Republic of China[EB/OL]. Clyde & Co.[2024-12-5]. https://www.clydeco.com/en/insights/2024/05/space-law-and-arbitration-an-introduction-to-space.
[45] Jakhu R.Capacity building in space law and space policy[J]. Advances in Space Research, 2009, 44(9): 1051-1054.
[46] Van den Bossche, Peter. The TRIPS Agreement and WTO Dispute Settlement: Past, Present and Future[EB/OL]. World Trade Institute, Dec. 05, 2022. [2023-6-10]. https://www.wti.org/research/publications/1298/the..
[47] International cooperation in the peaceful uses of outer space[EB/OL].1959. [2023-6-10]. http://www.oosa.unvienna.org/oosa/COPUOS/copuos.html
[48] LIU H W, LUO J B.Sino-African Development Cooperation: Studies on the Theories, Strategies, and Policies[J]. Springer Nature, 2021.
[49] Frans G. von der Dunk. Effective Exercise of ‘In-Space Jurisdiction’: The US Approach and the Problems It Is Facing[J]. Journal of Space Law, 2016, 40(1-2): 147-185.
[50] Sergio Marchisio. National Jurisdiction for Regulating Space Activities of Governmental and Non-Governmental Entities[EB/OL]. Activities of States in Outer Space in Light of New Developments: Meeting International Responsibilities and Establishing National Legal and Policy Frameworks, Bangkok, Thailand: UNOOSA, Nov.2010: 7. [2024-8-15]. https://www.unoosa.org/pdf/pres/2010/SLW2010/02-02.pdf.
[51] Viikari Lotta.Dispute Resolution in the Space Sector: Present Status and Future Prospects[EB/OL]. Rovaniemi: Lapland University Press, 2008: 26, 2008, Accessed: Aug. 20, 2024. [Online]. Available: https://www.ulapland.fi/loader.aspx?id=a023c493-9028-46dd-a0bd-d7dc738d6b5d.
[52] Schwartz B, Berlin M L. After the Fall: An Analysis of Canadian Legal Claims for Damage Caused by Cosmos 954[J/OL]. McGill Law Journal, 1982, 27(4). https://lawjournal.mcgill.ca/article/after-the-fall-an-analysis-of-canadian-legal-claims-for-damage-caused-by-cosmos-954/.
[53] Vincenzo C.Resolving disputes in outer space: the role of international arbitration[EB/OL]. DLA PIPER.[2024-9-10]. https://www.dlapiper.com/en/insights/publications/2023/04/resolving-disputes-in-outer-space-the-role-of-international-arbitration.
[54] Benjamin Casey.Justice for the New Frontier: How the United Nations Creates a Space Court[EB/OL]. SSRN.[2024-9-15]. https://ssrn.com/abstract=4028709.
[55] Böckstiegel K.-H. First draft for a convention on the settlement of space law disputes[EB/OL]. 1984. http://digitallibrary.un.org/record/112053.
[56] Rafika Shari’ah binti Mohd Hassan. From Earth to Heaven: States’ Criminal Jurisdiction in The Space Station[J]. IIUM LAW JOURNAL, 2015, 23(3): 14.
[57] Ferreira-Snyman A.Challenges to the Prohibition on Sovereignty in Outer Space - A New Frontier for Space Governance[J]. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 2021, (24): 1-50.
[58] CAO Y M.Analyzing SpaceX’s International Collaborations: Conflicts and Coordination Mechanisms with Space Partners[J]. Highlights in Business, Economics and Management, 2024, 24: 6.
[59] Minchev E.Challenges to modern methods of dispute resolution with respect to outer space activities[J]. Journal of the Faculty of Law of the Federal University of Uberlândia, 2020, 47(2): 26.
[60] Consoli L D J, Chalkias P. Space Related Disputes Part1 - The Current Landscape and Specific Intellectual Property Aspects[EB/OL].Daily Jus. [2024-12-28]. https://dailyjus.com/world/2024/12/space-related-disputes-part-1-the-current-landscape-and-specific-intellectual-property-aspects.
[61] Atkins S.Dispute resolution and restructuring in outer space: Using ADR to drive efficiency and better outcomes for creditors[EB/OL]. Norton Rose Fulbright.[2024-9-17]. https://www.nortonrosefulbright.com/zh-hk/knowledge/publications/5bf5d3bb/dispute-resolution-and-restructuring-in-outer-space.
[62] Dreosti J, Brown M, Ruffié-Farrugia R, et al. Satellites and Space: using arbitration to resolve disputes in the new frontier[EB/OL]. Practical Law UK, May2023. https://www.cliffordchance.com/content/dam/cliffordchance/briefings/2023/06/satellites-and-space-using-arbitration-to-resolve-disputes-in-the-new-frontier.pdf.
[63] Aceris Law LLC.Reaching for the Stars: Arbitration of Space-Related Disputes,” Aceris Law[EB/OL]. [2024-8-15].https://www.acerislaw.com/reaching-for-the-stars-arbitration-of-space-related-disputes/.
[64] JIANG Z, CAO X L, HUANG X, et al.Progress and Development Trend of Space Intelligent Robot Technology[J]. Space: Science & Technology, 2022, 1: 1-11.
[65] WANG C, WNG J Y.Legal Regulation of Commercial Exploitation of Outer Space Resources and China’s Countermeasures[J]. Beijing Law Review, 2024, 15(3): 1040-1064.
[66] Foley J J. Planning International Collaborations on the Chinese Space Station[J/OL]. Journal of Science Policy & Governance, 2014, 5 (1). [2023-6-4]. https://issuu.com/jofspg/docs/j_foley.__2014___22planning_interna.
[67] XU F, OU J.Promoting international cooperation on the International Lunar Research Station: Inspiration from the ITER[J]. Acta Astronautica, 2023, 203: 341-350.
[68] Froehlich A. Space Resource Utilization: A View from an Emerging Space Faring Nation[M/OL]//vol. 12. in Studies in Space Policy. Springer Cham, 2018: 1868-5307. [2023-5-22]. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-66969-4.
[69] Osorno R, Koria M, Ramírez-Vázquez D.Open Innovation with Value Co-Creation from University-Industry Collaboration[J]. Journal of Open Innovation Technology Market and Complexity, 2022, 8(1): 32.
[70] Ogenga F.Kenya and the Emerging Power-Shift in Global Political-Economy: Right-Wing Populism and Social Media Activism[J]. Journalism and Mass Communication, 2020, 10(1).
[71] Otele O M.Introduction. China-Africa Relations: Interdisciplinary Question and Theoretical Perspectives[J]. The African Review, 2020, 47(2): 267-284.
[72] Duarte P.Beijing in the ‘land of opportunity’: assessing the Sino-African partnership[J]. AFRICANA STUDIA, 2012, 19.
[73] Monyae D, Band G. Sino-South African Relations at Twenty: Key Lessons[J/OL]. UJCI Africa-China Occasional Paper, 2018, (5): 1-20. [2023-3-20]. https://scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=view_citation&hl=en&user=JxfWDDIAAAAJ&citation_for_view=JxfWDDIAAAAJ:LkGwnXOMwfcC.
[74] Collins O O, Ejogba O A.Sino - Africa Relations And Africa’s Development: A Review Of Nigeria’s Experience From 1999 - 2020[J]. IJPREMS, 2023, 3(4): 1038-1045.
[75] KING K.China-Africa Education Cooperation: From FOCAC to Belt and Road[J]. ECNU Review of Education, 2019, 3: 209653111988987.
[76] Esiet E. Chinese and Australian Engagement with Africa: A Comparative Study[EB/OL]. Thesis, Bond University, 2022. [2023-8-11]. https://research.bond.edu.au/en/studentTheses/chinese-and-australian-engagement-with-africa-a-comparative-study.
[77] Hazzan M, H L L, Abeka F. China-Africa cooperation and challenges related to the belt and road initiative[J]. African Educational Research Journal, 2023, 11: 651-664.
[78] Shaun K, Laura R. Africa’s agency in the competing narratives of external partners in Africa’s digital market A comparison of Japan and China[EB/OL]. University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, Sep.2023. [2024-1-1]. https://hdl.handle.net/10539/37676.
[79] ZHU J.The Personal Information Protection Law: China’s Version of the GDPR?” Columbia Journal of Transnational Law[EB/OL]. [2024-11-19].https://www.jtl.columbia.edu/bulletin-blog/the-personal-information-protection-law-chinas-version-of-the-gdpr.
[80] Secure Privacy.Protecting Your Personal Information in the Age of the Personal Information Protection Law (PIPL) by the People’s Republic of China[EB/OL]. Secure Privacy.[2024-9-15]. https://secureprivacy.ai/blog/china-pipl-personal-information-protection-law.
[81] Desai A.South Africa’s Protection of Personal Information Act (POPIA) Explainedy[EB/OL]. [2025-1-20].https://termly.io/resources/articles/south-africas-protection-of-personal-information-act/.
[82] Agwu F A. Foreign Policy in the Age of Globalization, Populism and Nationalism[M/OL]. Springer Singapore, 2021. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-16-3372-0.
[83] Charles Onyango Ochieng’, Raphael Akeyo. A basic assessment of the impacts of Sino-Africa relations on Africa[EB/OL]. Jun.2020. [2023-3-15]. https://www.academia.edu/43793430/A_basic_assessment_of_the_impacts_of_Sino_Africa_relations_on_Africa.
[84] ESPI. UN resolution on norms of responsible behaviours in space: a step forward to preserve stability in space?[EB/OL]. European Space Policy Institute. https://www.espi.or.at/briefs/un-resolution-on-norms-of-responsible-behaviours-in-space/.